Toby’s Room, by Pat Barker


Purchased from the Book Depository

Purchased from the Book Depository

Serious readers of literature inevitably find themselves reading at least a sampling of war fiction. Homer probably deserves the title of “founding father” for the genre back in the 8th century B.C.; Kevin Powers (The Yellow Birds) and Ben Fountain (Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk) were the latest to join the list of practitioners with well-reviewed novels published in 2012 concerning the Iraqi War. It is, alas, part of the sad history of humanity that there has been a rare time in the 29 centuries in between that there hasn’t been a conflict available for fiction writers to explore.

Given the breadth and depth of war fiction, it is equally inevitable that each reader will have a “best of genre” selection. For this reader, that nod goes to Pat Barker for her Regeneration trilogy (Regeneration, The Eye in the Door and the Booker Prize winning Ghost Road). The first novel is the author’s version of the story of anti-war poet Siegfried Sassoon and neurologist/psychoanalyst/anthropologist W.H.R. Rivers’ treatment of his shell shock. While Regeneration is mainly about the upper class men who fought in WWI, Barker discovers some interesting working class characters in that process — Rivers is present in all three volumes of the trilogy, but the plebian officer Billy Prior moves to the centre in the concluding one. Taken together, the three are as good an examination as I have read of the effects of war on the individuals and societies involved (okay, Tolstoy did a pretty fair job on the same themes as well).

The trilogy was my introduction to Barker (pre-blog, unfortunately, so there are no reviews here) and I have been a reader of both her back catalogue and new works ever since. She struck another responsive chord with KfC in 2007 with Life Class. I have an affection for novels about art and artists — this one focuses on a group of students (like the characters in Regeneration, many drawn from real life) at London’s Slade School of Fine Art in the years leading up to WWI.

All of which is a long introduction to explain why I was looking forward to Toby’s Room. It returns to many of the characters who featured in Life Class (but you don’t have to have read that one to appreciate this one). They have now graduated, only to find themselves part of the British war effort rather than practising artists, taking us into the world of the Regeneration trilogy.

All Barker’s novels, characters and plots have their dark sides and in Toby’s Room she wastes little time exposing them. We first meet the narrator, Elinor Brooke, in 1912 on a return home from the Slade for a family weekend — the only thing she is looking forward to about it is seeing her brother Toby, also in London as a medical student but they rarely see each other there. The two take a walk to their childhood hideaway, a disused mill. Childhood memories suddenly give way to present impulses:

He grabbed her arms and pulled her towards him. Crushed against his chest, hardly able to breathe, she laughed and struggled, taking this for the start of some childish game, but then his lips fastened on to hers with a groping hunger that shocked her into stillness. His tongue thrust between her lips, a strong, muscular presence. She felt his chin rough against her cheek, the breadth of his chest and shoulders, not that round, androgynous, childish softness that had sometimes made them seem like two halves of a single person. She started to struggle again, really struggle, but his hand came up and cupped her breast and she felt herself softening, flowing towards him, as if something hard and impacted in the pit of her stomach had begun to melt.

Both are shocked by what has happened but that “melting” does not stop: Elinor goes to Toby’s room that night and the two consummate their “affair”.

Having given us incest in chapter one, Barker does not let up in the next few chapters. Through the combined influence of the Slade’s director, Henry Tonks (one of the real-life characters in the novel), and Toby, Elinor has been allowed to enrol in an anatomy lab at the medical school — Tonks believes that a hands-on knowledge of anatomy will improve her drawing. Here is Elinor meeting her cadaver:

Mantegna’s Dead Christ. From where Elinor stood at the foot of the slab, the feet appeared huge, out of all proportion to the body. His face was dark, the eyes shuttered; nobody could have mistaken this stillness for sleep. Freed from the apprehension of an answering gaze, she let her eyes slide down, across the soaring chancel arch of his ribcage, along the flat nave of his belly to where his penis lay, a shrivelled seahorse on an outcrop of wrinkled and sagging skin.

Barker shows no pity for the squeamish reader — several chapters are devoted to the complete dissection of the cadaver. Like the incest she introduced at the start of the book, this supplies context that will prove essential in later sections.

Not of all that context-setting is quite so gruesome. Barker also introduces two of Elinor’s fellow students at the Slade — the upper-class fop, Kit Neville, and Paul Tarrant, a working class lad lucky to get into the toffy school. When we get to the present-day narrative that forms the bulk of the book five years later in 1917, these three (with a strong supporting role for Tonks) become the driving cast of the novel.

That present day thread is set in motion with the arrival of a telegram announcing that Toby is “Missing, Believed Killed” in France. It is a telegram that leads to an obsession for Elinor: Is Toby truly dead? And what really happened?

She first enlists the help of Tarrant, to whom she was briefly engaged, now back from the war because of a serious leg injury, but starting a new career as a government-paid war artist. Kit Neville was part of Toby’s unit when he went missing — Elinor and Paul track him down at Queen’s Hospital, Sidcup, Kent where he is having his face re-built as a result of his own war injury. And, just to complete the circle, Tonks is working at the hospital, sketching the faces of patients as they undergo reconstructive surgery (this too is real — you can find some of the sketches online here). Tonks hires Elinor as an assistant portraitist — the process of getting Neville to reveal the story proves to be a long one so she is eager to be on site.

Did Toby’s Room replace the Regeneration trilogy in my “war genre” ranking? No — it didn’t come close to accomplishing that, but do not take that as a criticism. In the final analysis of this novel, the war experience actually is more background than foreground; this is a novel about how fractured individuals (which we all are) come face-to-face with life-crippling events. Barker is not just a realist writer, she is ruthless in her realism, a trait shared by few novelists. Undoubtedly, that may prove too much for some (and I can understand why); for this reader, it was again proof positive that Barker is an exceptional novelist, one whom I will keep reading as long as she keeps writing.

15 Responses to “Toby’s Room, by Pat Barker”

  1. Lisa Hill Says:

    Yes, onto my wishlist it goes, I think she’s one of the best authors writing in the UK today.
    Oddly, one I didn’t like so much is the one that stays with me most, Border Crossing. I often find myself thinking about the characters in that one.


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      I haven’t read Border Crossing yet but reviews suggest it seems similar (to me, at least) to ones that I have in the sense that Barker uses some troubling and disturbing situations to do what she does best — develop characters.


  2. Guy Savage Says:

    Thanks Kevin: I’ve yet to read this but I won a copy of it. Agree with you on the Regeneration Trilogy


  3. leroyhunter Says:

    I’ve been reading a lot of Great War books in recent years – Graves, Barbusse, Junger, Manning, Blunden, Remarque – and I have 2 volumes of Sassoon on the shelf. For that reason Barker intrigues me yet there’s somthing that keeps putting me off the trilogy. She seems to be quite divisive. Or maybe I’ve just read some particularly negative views that have lodged in mind. But the praise you offer her work (aloong with Guy) is persuasive Kevin.


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      The trilogy does seem divisive — I suspect because readers have different expectations of what is “good” when it comes to war fiction. I felt when I read it that Barker may well have started off intending only to write about Sassoon and that story, but discovered in Regeneration some characters (Rivers and Billy) who warranted further attention. I am one of those who thinks that the second and third novels are somewhat weaker than the first (still fine, however).

      What is consistent in her work is the writing — for me, she has a style that engages me from the beginning and draws me fully into some very unlikely scenes (like the details of what happens in a dissection lab).


  4. acommonreaderuk Says:

    Like you, my reading of the regeneration trilogy was pre-blog and I’ve never thought of revisiting the author since. Barker is a very serious writer and she repays investigation into what lies behind the printed page. This one sounds as though it could be a bit of an ordeal with the incest and the dissections. While it may not be a book I would rush out and buy, I’ve now ordered it from the library but may have to wait a few weeks before it arrives.


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      Barker is easier to read than she is to write about. She definitely wants to set her readers on edge with some disturbing material but does manage to do it in a way that causes me to think, rather than just get shocked.

      As much as I appreciated it, I have not returned to the Regeneration trilogy either. I am not a particularly avid reader of war fiction as a genre — which means I still have quite a few war “classics” to get to a first time.


  5. Max Cairnduff Says:

    The Illiad remains my touchstone for war fiction, but as you say at the end this clearly isn’t attempting the same kind of exploration. It does sound difficult, which I mean as a compliment.

    Do you know what draws Barker to this period so strongly?


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      As for your question: Barker’s first three novels (I have only read Union Street) were all working class, feminist, set in the industrial north. According to Wikipedia, she didn’t want to be labelled as an author of working class, feminist, northern novels, so she moved to the Great War, inspired by her stepgrandfather. As far as I can tell, every novel since those first three has been set in that time period. That will draw no complaints from me — as in this novel, she tends to draw tangential lines off of the central war story. Who would have thought that war atrocities would lead to sub-themes on Polynesian customs (as in Ghost Road)?


  6. Louise Says:

    I was fortunate enough to hear Pat Barker talking at the Ilkley Literature Festival last autumn. It was interesting to hear her talk about the mental and creative processes she went through in writing what was initially intended to be one book, and ‘grew’ into three (in the Regeneration Trilogy).
    I’ve just found this interesting clip of her talking about why writing about the psychological impact of War has become such a recurring theme.


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      Many thanks for the comment. I have always felt that Barker did not start out to write a trilogy but discovered some characters and ideas that needed further exploration when she wrote Regeneration — so I am glad to have that impression confirmed.

      And the link you include should offer Max some thoughts in response to his question in the previous comment.


  7. Deirdre O'Brien Says:

    I think Barker is a marvellous writer but, after reading several of her novels, I found her just too depressing and decided I wouldn’t read anything else of hers. I wish she would write a happier book.


  8. sharkell Says:

    I have just finished reading Toby’s Room, my first Barker, which I picked up as a result of your review. I’m still reeling from it a bit, especially after having seen the Tonks pastels on the website you refer to. I found it compelling reading and I loved the style of writing. Now I can’t wait to read more of Barker’s books. I have Life Class on my tbr so I may start there (and perhaps I should have read that one first having re-read your review…)


    • KevinfromCanada Says:

      I would read Life Class next — although that is by way of saying that I think you will like Barker well enough that you probably want to “save” the Regeneration trilogy for when you can get to it.

      I don’t think reading them out of order will be a problem — at least, I didn’t find any parts in Toby’s Room that relied on what I remembered from the previous novel. Yes, you are going to be meeting younger versions of some of the characters who were in this one, but that just makes it like an extended flashback.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: