The Shadow Giller Jury is back!


Canada’s Giller Prize season gets under way with release of the longlist Sept. 4 — so it is time to confirm that the Shadow Giller Jury will again be in action and declaring its “winner” in advance of the Real Jury selection on Oct. 30.

Regular visitors at KfC are undoubtedly familiar with the Shadow Giller but for newcomers here is a short bit of background. This is year 18 for the Real Giller: the Shadow Giller has been in existence for 17 of those years. It is based on the assumption that those readers who want to criticize a prize jury have a duty to make their own choice known in advance of the real selection. We started in 1995 with a 20-minute conversation in the newsroom of the Calgary Herald (and agreed with the Real Jury and selected Rohinton Mistry’s A Fine Balance as our winner). For many of the following years, the Shadow Giller held an annual judging “lunch” (a pale imitation of the Real Giller banquet) — it must be admitted that a few years we were reduced to a telephone conference call, but we have always announced our choice before the real selection was made. And I’ve always been able to recruit at least a couple of people who were delighted to serve as Shadow jurors.

Since the KevinfromCanada blog started four years ago, it has served as headquarters for the Shadow Giller and will again this year. Like the Real Giller, we feature an international jury (the Real Jury this year is Irish author Roddy Doyle; Leningrad-born, now U.S.-based, author Gary Shteyngart; and Canadian Anna Porter, a former book publisher). This year’s Shadow Jury is the same as last year’s: Kimbofo in London, England who blogs at Reading Matters; Trevor, who has recently relocated from New Jersey to Utah, at the Mookse and the Gripes and Alison Gzowski, an editor at the Globe and Mail and former producer of CBC’s Talking Books, who doesn’t blog but offers her thoughts on all three that are involved.

This year’s Real Giller has already provoked some discussion: the original longlist date of Aug. 28 was pushed back a week, supposedly to give jurors time to read all the books. Conspiracy theorists (what would a literary prize be without a conspiracy?) might spot early jury disagreement. On the other hand, the 2012 Canadian publishing schedule is even more fall-loaded than normal, so the official rationale is probably legitimate.

The shortlist date (Oct. 1) was not changed so the Shadow Giller faces the same challenge as in previous years. There simply will not be enough time for us to all read the entire longlist. As before, we promise that at least one of us will read and review each of the longlisted titles — some of those reviews will appear on Kim and Trevor’s blogs, but I’ll be posting excerpts and links to their reviews here. And Alison will also be offering the occasional guest review here.

We again commit to all four of us reading (and reviewing) the entire shortlist — in addition to my own reviews, I will again be offering excerpts and links to those of Kim and Trevor. Comments from fellow travellers are most welcome at all three blogs.

All four of us also pay some attention to the Booker Prize and last year found the Giller list to be far more interesting reading than the Booker. It is a better Booker list this year, but I still give the Giller a good shot at coming up with a better list — I’m certainly looking forward to the reading.

And if you want to jump the gun, the Giller people have again compiled a list of the more than 200 titles that were eligible for submission for the 2012 Prize — you can browse that entire list here.

We look forward to others joining in the Shadow Giller journey. As I said earlier, your comments and thoughts are always welcome.


6 Responses to “The Shadow Giller Jury is back!”

  1. Guy Savage Says:

    There’s a fair number of crime novels, Kevin


  2. KevinfromCanada Says:

    Guy: Well, we have a lot of crime in Canada. 🙂

    Actually, the third winner of the prize, Margaret Atwood’s Alias Grace, is pretty much a crime novel, although I don’t think “crime novelist” shows up very often in descriptions of Atwood.

    There is an opening on the Shadow Jury for a crime specialist if you would be interested.


  3. David Says:

    I’m really looking forward to the Giller longlist and to following the shadow jury’s reviews. I reckon it could potentially be another very strong list, just from the books I’ve read and the reviews I’ve seen of those I haven’t.
    As Guy says, a lot of crime novels are eligible but then they always are – very few make it to the longlist. One novel I’ve read this year that was sort of a Crime novel which I could see as having an outside chance of making the longlist would be Matt Lennox’s ‘The Carpenter’, but it’s ‘Crime’ in the way that some of David Adams Richards’ books could be categorised as ‘Crime’.


  4. KevinfromCanada Says:

    David: I agree — just because crime novels show up on the complete publication list doesn’t mean many make the longlist. And those that do (Clara Callan is another winner with a “crime” element) tend to be more literary than crime.

    I am virtually certain that when the longlist is announced a week from today you will have read more of them than any of the Shadow jurors — your interest and commitment to Canadian fiction is a tribute to the breadth of your reading. I’m hoping (fingers crossed) that I will have read and reviewed three or four here — I would not be at all surprised if you know more than half the list. Whatever (and I don’t try to predict Giller longlists), your comments will certainly be welcome when the list is announced


  5. Trish Osuch (@trishosuch) Says:

    Looking forward to this, as always! I’ll be reading as many of the longlisted titles as possible as well. Will be sure to chime in. Good luck, Shadow Giller team!


  6. KevinfromCanada Says:

    Thanks, Trish. We look forward to your thoughts. And I am sure there is a lot of rewarding reading ahead of us.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: