Governor-General’s award winner a surprise


Kate Pullinger’s The Mistress of Nothing has won the 2009 Governor-General’s award for English language fiction — a major and stunning surprise. Told from the point of view of her servant, the book is the story of Lady Duff Cooper’s mid-nineteenth century retreat to Egypt to alleviate her consumption and how the household adapts there ( my full review is here). I said in my original review that I was surprised to see the novel shortlisted for the G-G and longlisted for the Giller — while it is very competently done, it is not the kind of book that wins literary competitions. As well, Pullinger, while Canadian-born and (I presume) still a citizen, has lived in London for almost a quarter century and the book has no Canadian content.

Juries for the G-G have a history of being contrarian. Alice Munro’s Too Much Happiness (reviewed here) would seem to have been this year’s obvious choice (and would have been mine) — one can only assume the jury decided that the Man Booker International Prize was award enough for Munro this year. Given that the last two G-G winners were established Canadian “names” (Nino Ricci for The Origin of the Species in 2008 and Michael Ondaatje for Divisadero in 2007), one could understand a jury wanting to look for something less obvious.

Even then, one would have thought the jury would turn to Annabel Lyon’s The Golden Mean (reviewed here ) as its next choice. This first novel about Aristotle and the young Alexander the Great is the success story of this year’s Canadian season, making the shortlist for all three major prizes. Alas, like Rawi Hage’s Cockroach last year it is now on track to lose all three.

The other two finalists would also have been surprise winners. Deborah Willis’ Vanishing and Other Stories (reviewed here is a wonderful first collection of stories, but not up to comparison with Munro. And Michael Crummey’s Galore (reviewed by Shadow Giller juror Trevor Berrett here) seems a bit too regional and offbeat — although that is often a strength in G-G competitions.

None of those comments is meant to discourage anyone from reading The Mistress of Nothing. While both the subject and style mean it is not for everyone’s taste, it is well done and an enjoyable read. It is, however, a surprising winner in a competiton where the “literary” usually takes precedence over the “readable”.

While I only follow the English fiction award, there are actually 14 Governor-General literary awards, seven each for English and French-language work, in categories including poetry, drama, children’s and translation. You can see the full list here.

4 Responses to “Governor-General’s award winner a surprise”

  1. Maggie Says:

    Yes – a surprise. I have not read the Pullinger since it did not get great reviews on this blog or really standout reviews elsewhere but did read Alice Munro, Annabel Lyon and Michael Crummey – thinking for sure nothing comes close to Munro but would have been equally happy to see Lyon or Crummey be honoured. I will now read the Pullinger and boy – it must be pretty amazing to top these folks.


  2. KevinfromCanada Says:

    Maggie: I agree — I could make a case for any of those three in terms of what I traditionally expect from G-G fiction juries. There is nothing the matter with this book; it is well-written, has an engaging story and moves at a quick pace (I’ve recommended it to several friends as a good “airplane” book). On the other hand, the format is quite traditional; it is not what I would call literary and has no Canadian connection whatsoever — so I can’t figure out what moved it ahead of the other four. Then again, my record at predicting jury outcomes is not really outstanding. Still, I enjoy making the effort.


  3. Elayne Harris Says:

    where’s the review of Galore, please?


  4. KevinfromCanada Says:

    Elayne: I tried Michael Crummey’s book and it simply wasn’t to my taste. Rather than forcing myself to finish and then rubbish it, I let my fellow Shadow Giller judge Trevor at theMookseandtheGripes offer a much better opinion than I could. You can access his review here.

    Sorry about that.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: